PDA

View Full Version : Disturbing Googling


ms.peachy
12-09-2005, 07:19 AM
OK, so here's something that's kind of freaking me out a bit.

I am working with a kid who is really interested in fossils. So, I'm putting together a list of websites for him to use for reference. And so I'm surfing about a bit on the net, looking for reputable sites with good information on how they form and what scientists can learn by studying them.

So, I wanted to be sure to have a source of info available for him on what radioisotope dating is and how its used to place things within the fossil record, and I googled the words "radioisotope dating".

Out of the 10 links on the first page, fully six of them were from ultraconservative creationist organisations, and only two contained any real information. (The remaining two were editorials.)

Now I am not accusing Google of having a creationist bias or agenda per se, insofar as I understand their 'page rank' system to work, but still, ve scary. Because it mean that if it's not Google's agenda, then there are an awful lot of people out there accessing that rubbish creationist crap.

If had just said to this kid, "Go see what you can learn about how scientists use radioisotope dating to place discoveries within the fossil record," he's 14, he wouldn't neccessarily have the breadth of experience to say 'hey wait, this isn't a science website, this is a religious site," you know?

Grrrrr. I can't stand those Young Earth nutjobs. I really can't.

MagicCowboy
12-09-2005, 07:22 AM
I agree.


I don't really have anything more to add to this thread :o

tracky
12-09-2005, 08:50 AM
Interesting

It could be that the creationists are actively seeking ranking for "radioisotope dating" while the scientific community relies on random links in forums etc

It is one of the places where google's page rank really falls down, in that it can be influenced by groups of people. And the larger the group, the bigger the influence. We (by that I mean the bbmb population) could in theory choose a word and a site, and by linking to that site using the word in the link text, get a site to #1 for that query. It really depends also on the word, the more obscure the better.

jabumbo
12-09-2005, 10:01 AM
for one of my classes this semester, i had to read a 40 page journal article about how the earth is an artifact

then i had to read sombody elses follow up on the article about how the first guy is wrong


great fun it was! :rolleyes: