Log in

View Full Version : First scathing review from Philadelphia Weekly


gaselite
03-30-2006, 12:34 AM
in the tradition of posting a thread about every tidbit of awesome news possible, I present you this:

Awesome; I Fuckin' Shot That!
Directed by Nathanial Hörnblowér
D+
Reviewed by Sean Burns
Opens Fri., March 31

I'm unclear on the specifics of that old adage about a hundred monkeys at a hundred typewriters eventually being able to churn out the collected works of Shakespeare, but thanks to the Beastie Boys' wretched Awesome; I Fuckin' Shot That! I'm now 100 percent certain that 50 bouncing, drunken concertgoers armed with consumer-model camcorders cannot produce a watchable record of their evening out.

As explained in a clever opening goof on Scarface, the Boys provided cheap video cameras to a whole slew of lucky ticket holders at a Madison Square Garden show in October 2004. The resulting mountain of shaky amateur footage has been edited within an inch of its life into Awesome; I Fuckin' Shot That!, presumably supplying us with the fans'-eye perspective of the sacred event.

This kind of thing probably sounds like a really cool idea when you're high.

Awesome; I Fuckin' Shot That! is a visual monstrosity-a machine-gun onslaught of herky-jerky underlit shots blown up on the big screen with pixels the size of cantaloupes. The Boys themselves must've at some point in the process realized the inherent stupidity of their concept, as there's plenty of high-quality professional footage peppered into the mix, as well as a ton of cheesy retro-'80s video color effects that turn the on-screen images into blurry abstractions for huge stretches of time. There are also endless trips to the concession stand, and one of the aspiring young videographers is considerate enough to bring the camera along with him to the men's room.

Having seen the Beastie Boys live when I was in high school, I can attest that it's not all that much of a show we're missing. (Though, were I offered a choice, I doubt I'd rather watch some stranger pee out what seems to be a healthy number of MSG's famous $6 beers.) They tend to run around the stage and shout a lot while Mix Master Mike spins some records, although in this film there's also a brief instrumental interlude devoted to their tedious lounge jams.

MCA (aka Adam Yauch, who here takes directorial credit under his usual pseudonym Nathanial Hörnblowér) has gray hair now, which was quite a sad reality check for this particular child of Licensed to Ill. There's a strange dissonance to the set list, as the Boys' recent awkwardly earnest message music butts uncomfortably against all those priceless old anthems about how totally awesome it is to be young, dumb and shitfaced.

The most revealing moment comes during the great warhorse "Paul Revere," which ignites the crowd into such a deafening sing-along that gray old MCA puts down the mike and takes a little rest-sitting down on the stage to get a better view of the bedlam.

I guess if you're gonna have the crowd shoot your concert movie for you, you might as well let them sing the songs too.



Fool

DandyFop
03-30-2006, 12:45 AM
"endless" trips to the concession stand??

Was this guy watching the same movie?

dave790
03-30-2006, 01:31 AM
fuck it, he clearly doesn't like them.

FunkyHiFi
03-30-2006, 04:02 AM
fuck it, he clearly doesn't like them.
I second this.

Kid Presentable
03-30-2006, 04:14 AM
It was only a matter of time.

Still, I'm not bothered.:D

midzi
03-30-2006, 04:33 AM
another one from http://today.reuters.com/news/newsArticle.aspx?type=reviewsNews&storyID=2006-03-30T080601Z_01_N30237298_RTRIDST_0_REVIEW-FILM-AWESOME-DC.XML

Beastie Boys concert film not that 'Awesome'


By Kirk Honeycutt

LOS ANGELES (Hollywood Reporter) - There is nothing new about moviemakers employing nonprofessionals. The recent Berlin festival winner "Longing" used only nonpro actors. Lars von Trier cast singer Bjork as his lead in "Dancer in the Dark," and the 2000 Cannes jury declared her its best actress. The great French filmmaker Robert Bresson even refused to work with professional actors. So there is nothing really shocking about the hip-hop/rap band Beastie Boys handing out lightweight digital cameras to 50 fans to shoot a concert film for them.

Predictably, "Awesome; I F-----' Shot That!" features crude footage. But this has been so manipulated in the lab and editing room that the film suffers little damage from the less-than-awesome footage. However, you've got to pity the editors for the head- and eye-aching job of wading through all that photographic junk for more than a year.

The sound, of course, is clear and sharp. Director Nathanial Hornblower -- the pseudonym for band member Adam Yauch -- isn't going to go the amateur route with his own music. So "Awesome" will please fans of the band, but expect little crossover to nonfans. No new ground is broken here. From a cinematic point of view, "Awesome" represents simply a monumental postproduction salvaging effort.

Clearly, a few ringers were mixed in with the 50 amateurs. Angles on or near the stage demonstrate professional aplomb (not to mention professional equipment). As for the footage from 50 fans, what you get is what you'd expect -- barely focused shots with constantly changing color and light values often from poor locations. The fellow who took his camera into the men's room and shot himself urinating perhaps best captures the spirit of the movie.

As the 89-minute movie wears on, the lab takes over: A freeze-frame leads to a shift from a positive to a negative image. One musical number goes black-and-white. Another indulges in saturated psychedelic colors. There are multiple split screens, superimpostions and solarized images.

After nearly 20 years, the band -- Mike D (Michael Diamond), Ad-Rock (Adam Horowitz) and MCA (Yauch) -- still performs with youthful energy and enthusiasm. If anything, the New York band seems a little in awe of the fact this particular gig, shot October 9, 2004, takes place in the historic Madison Square Garden. They even have the courage to go into the audience to perform one number with minimum security. The backbone of the show for at least this performance comes from DJ Mix Master Mike. Doug E. Fresh puts in a special appearance as does drummer Alfredo Ortiz and keyboardist Money Mark.

For the record, at the press screening, the film was projected digitally in HDcam.

gaselite
03-30-2006, 05:49 AM
that one's not too bad, although the non-professional preamble strikes me as irrelevant. Firstly for comparing it to narrative films, secondly, the fact that they're non-professional isn't the point, it's the fact that they're fans. For all the crew knew there could have been some professional, trained cameramen who applied to be given a camera who are also fans of the Beasties, but that would be beside the point completely.

Still, the point about this film not looking so great on a big screen is a fair point. I think the film would be ideal for DVD in so many ways, can't wait for it.

enree erzweglle
03-30-2006, 08:05 AM
Maybe he was expecting we-are-the-world zippo-lighting arms-waving-overhead kinds of footage. How Journey's 30th Anniversary Reunion Tour.

The most revealing moment comes during the great warhorse "Paul Revere," which ignites the crowd into such a deafening sing-along that gray old MCA puts down the mike and takes a little rest-sitting down on the stage to get a better view of the bedlam.Can't this guy read people? That was a sweet moment because Yauch was trying to get closer to the crowd and, in fact, at times, he actually does go into the crowd and that is nice.

The guy seems to equate having grey hair with being old with being subpar.

Gobby
03-30-2006, 02:13 PM
Whatever, this guy obviously doesn't like the Beastie Boys. He liked them in the 80s, and now he doesn't like them because they aren't really the same band.

And "tedious lounge jams"? Their instrumentals are awesome.

abcdefz
03-30-2006, 02:54 PM
So far, out of 17 reviews, 14 are positive.

Rotten Tomatoes. (http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/awesome_i_fuckin_shot_that/)

YoungRemy
03-30-2006, 03:39 PM
one mans ceiling is another mans floor...

for every negative review, there are ten positive ones...


this guy is unoriginal, he is the third writer to use the monkey/typewriter/shakespeare reference...

and they all end the same, the writer wishes he were hip and young again, but his old crochety ass had to sit through the movie because he was hired to write the review...

some people just dont get it... its a fucking concert, what did they expect?