Log in

View Full Version : Palin quoted from a racist, anti-Semite who advocated assassination of FDR and RFK


DroppinScience
10-13-2008, 08:03 PM
This one reeeeeally slipped the radar, but in Palin's convention speech, she used a quote from Westbrook Pegler, a columnist who actually openly advocated for FDR and RFK's assassinations.

This is taken from Frank Rich's column (from the NY Times) which addresses whether McCain and Palin are doing enough to stop hate speech in their rallies.

http://www.commondreams.org/view/2008/10/12-6

Excerpt below:

From the start, there have always been two separate but equal questions about race in this election. Is there still enough racism in America to prevent a black man from being elected president no matter what? And, will Republicans play the race card? The jury is out on the first question until Nov. 4. But we now have the unambiguous answer to the second: Yes.

McCain, who is no racist, turned to this desperate strategy only as Obama started to pull ahead. The tone was set at the Republican convention, with Rudy Giuliani's mocking dismissal of Obama as an "only in America" affirmative-action baby. We also learned then that the McCain campaign had recruited as a Palin handler none other than Tucker Eskew, the South Carolina consultant who had worked for George W. Bush in the notorious 2000 G.O.P. primary battle where the McCains and their adopted Bangladeshi daughter were slimed by vicious racist rumors.

No less disconcerting was a still-unexplained passage of Palin's convention speech: Her use of an unattributed quote praising small-town America (as opposed to, say, Chicago and its community organizers) from Westbrook Pegler, the mid-century Hearst columnist famous for his anti-Semitism, racism and violent rhetorical excess. After an assassin tried to kill F.D.R. at a Florida rally and murdered Chicago's mayor instead in 1933, Pegler wrote that it was "regrettable that Giuseppe Zangara shot the wrong man." In the '60s, Pegler had a wish for Bobby Kennedy: "Some white patriot of the Southern tier will spatter his spoonful of brains in public premises before the snow falls."

This is the writer who found his way into a speech by a potential vice president at a national political convention. It's astonishing there's been no demand for a public accounting from the McCain campaign. Imagine if Obama had quoted a Black Panther or Louis Farrakhan - or William Ayers - in Denver.

Just from this passage alone, there is a lot of troubling facts. Tucker Eskew (the man who spread the whisper campaign in 2000 that McCain fathered a black baby) being recruited by the McCain campaign is beyond fucked up.

Next, Palin just quoting Hegler is flat-out alarming. Granted, Palin wasn't quoting a racist or anti-Semtic quote, but just the notion that she finds the ideas of a noted bigot worth merit just screams wrong.

King PSYZ
10-13-2008, 09:34 PM
so let's recount... Obama recounts a fairly common meme about McCain in a speach and because he didn't credit it to a cartoonist he got slammed by the GOP Pretty Hate Machine...

Palin uses a uncredited quote, from a psycho biggot no less..., and that's hunky dory bill ayers , ok so can we move on now bill ayers ? thanks...

makes sense to me

:confused:

Bob
10-13-2008, 09:36 PM
what was the quote?

King PSYZ
10-13-2008, 09:50 PM
what was the quote?

As much as I hate quoting wikipedia, until I can find another source here ya go

Interest in Pegler was revived when a line originally written by him appeared in Republican Vice-Presidential nominee Sarah Palin's acceptance speech at the 2008 Republican National Convention in St. Paul, Minnesota. "We grow good people in our small towns, with honesty and sincerity and dignity", she said, attributing it to "a writer."[10] The speech was written by Matthew Scully, a senior speech writer for George W. Bush.[11]

If this can be refuted, please do so.

Funny how she wouldn't quote the source other than the broad stroke term of writer. Sorry, that doesn't cut the mustard. And it brings into question why she's refrencing a biggot when there's all kinds of americana quotes out there about good ol small town folk being the salt of the earth etc.

Documad
10-14-2008, 12:40 AM
There's no way she pulled that quote herself or knew who said it before. I was written by someone and put into a speech. I couldn't have identified the quote myself, and I'm sure I'm more well read that Palin. I think she deserves a pass on this, but McCain's speechwriter pulled that quote and he should have known better. Just another of the hundreds of examples of how badly run McCain's campaign is, and what poor taste he has in employees.

King PSYZ
10-14-2008, 01:35 AM
I know the answer to my own question here, but for the sake of discourse...

So we know most have speachwriters, it can be helpful to have someone help put into a clear concise statement what one's personal goals and message is.

You would of course expect the canidate to then work with and approve any quotes.

If she is unaware of the quotes or it's possible connotation, it proves her inablity and unpreparedness for the job at hand.

If she did work with and consult the writer of the speach, why did she not question the source of the quotes and who it's attributed to when at the same time the campaign was slamming Obama for an unatributed quote...

jennyb
10-14-2008, 09:41 AM
I believe her convention speech was written by one of George dubya's speech writers. ya...