Log in

View Full Version : Reporters Notebook: What Really Happens at Tea Party Rallies.


RobMoney$
04-07-2010, 05:16 PM
http://www.cnn.com/2010/POLITICS/04/07/tea.party.rallies/index.html?eref=rss_politics&utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+rss%2Fcnn_allpolitics+%28RSS% 3A+Politics%29&utm_content=Google+Feedfetcher

STORY HIGHLIGHTS
CNN's Shannon Travis planned coverage of Tea Party Express for five stops in two weeks
The stereotypes don't tell the whole story, he says
Being at a Tea Party rally is not quite like seeing it on TV, he says
Travis witnessed not just anger, but also optimism


RELATED TOPICS
Tea Party Movement
U.S. Politics
Protests and Demonstrations
(CNN) -- When it comes to the Tea Party movement, the stereotypes don't tell the whole story.

Here's what you often see in the coverage of Tea Party rallies: offensive posters blasting President Obama and Democratic leaders; racist rhetoric spewed from what seems to be a largely white, male audience; and angry protesters rallying around the Constitution.

Case in point: During the health care debate last month, opponents shouted racial slurs at civil rights icon Georgia Rep. John Lewis and one person spit on Missouri Rep. Emanuel Cleaver. The incidents made national headlines, and they provided Tea Party opponents with fodder to question the movement.

But here's what you don't often see in the coverage of Tea Party rallies: Patriotic signs professing a love for country; mothers and fathers with their children; African-Americans proudly participating; and senior citizens bopping to a hip-hop rapper.

Last week, I saw all of this during a five-city Western swing as the Tea Party Express national tour made its way across the country. CNN was along for the ride, and I was charged with planning CNN's coverage for five stops in two states: St. George, Provo and Salt Lake City, Utah; and Grand Junction and Denver, Colorado.

This latest Tea Party caravan kicked off on March 27 in Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid's hometown of Searchlight, Nevada. It is scheduled to make 45 stops before rolling into Washington on April 15, not so coincidentally on "Tax Day."

CNN was the only national news outlet on this Western leg of the tour. We had a full team on the ground: myself, correspondent Ed Lavandera, producers Tracy Sabo and Jim Spellman and the crew of the CNN Express bus. For Spellman, it was his third Tea Party Express tour.

Together, we beamed out images of the anger and the optimism, profiled African-Americans who are proud to be in the Tea Party's minority and showed activists stirred by "God Bless America" or amused by a young rapper who strung together rhymes against the president and Democrats.

The CNN Express traveled with the Tea Party Express buses for hundreds of miles, from rally to rally to rally.

Being at a Tea Party rally is not quite like seeing it on TV, in newspapers or online. That's the reason CNN is covering this political movement -- and doing so in ways few others can or choose to do.

It is important to show the colorful anger Americans might have against elected leaders and Washington. But people should also see the orange-vested Tea Party hospitality handlers who welcome you with colorful smiles.

There were a few signs that could be seen as offensive to African-Americans. But by and large, no one I spoke with or I heard from on stage said anything that was approaching racist.

Almost everyone I met was welcoming to this African-American television news producer.

And though speakers railed against the "lame-stream media," activists and their leaders praised CNN, especially for being the only national media outlet riding along for the post-weekend stops. Some of them e-mailed me after my trip, thanking our crew for fairly giving them a voice.

Speaking of stereotypes, I did get a few curious stares as I pulled up to the rallies. But not because of my skin color. It was because of my car rental: a Volvo.

I hadn't intended to rent a Volvo, a car stereotyped as the favorite of liberal elites. But upon arriving at the Las Vegas airport, the rental company was out of American-made cars with a GPS system and satellite radio. I had nearly a thousand miles of driving ahead, through desert, mountains and cities. Since it had GPS and satellite radio, the Volvo fit the bill.

Outside of the occasional stare, none of the real cowboys at the rallies came up to the Volvo and asked me, "Hey buddy -- where's your cashmere sweater and arugula?" If they had, I might have pointed out that until just recently, Volvo was owned by Ford Motor Co., an American icon.

Jokes aside, stereotypes can loom large when they're magnified through a television lens, on the radio, the pages of a newspaper or in the vastness of the Internet.

So, it's important that with a newsworthy, growing phenomenon like the Tea Party movement, viewers and readers fully understand what they see and what they don't.


But it's more fun to report and talk about the lunatic fringe and act like those are the average person.

Whatitis
04-07-2010, 05:59 PM
More stereotyping (http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20100406/ap_on_re_us/us_tea_party_blacks_3).

DroppinScience
04-09-2010, 06:33 PM
Find two black people and you have a diverse movement!

EN[i]GMA
04-09-2010, 08:33 PM
Who cares?

yeahwho
04-10-2010, 01:10 AM
Being in the Tea Party is pretty much saying to yourself, I give up completely on ever getting laid again.

RobMoney$
04-10-2010, 02:23 PM
Find two black people and you have a diverse movement!


Consider this:
St. George, Provo and Salt Lake City, Utah; and Grand Junction and Denver, Colorado.
Frankly, the fact that there were any black people attending such an event in this area of the country surprised me.

Also, I find it highly suspect that a black man wrote: and senior citizens bopping to a hip-hop rapper.


It's nice to read some actual reporting for a change instead of the usual partisan spin were so used to getting from the media.

DroppinScience
04-10-2010, 04:23 PM
Consider this:
St. George, Provo and Salt Lake City, Utah; and Grand Junction and Denver, Colorado.
Frankly, the fact that there were any black people attending such an event in this area of the country surprised me.

Also, I find it highly suspect that a black man wrote: and senior citizens bopping to a hip-hop rapper.


It's nice to read some actual reporting for a change instead of the usual partisan spin were so used to getting from the media.

Get back to me when your Tea Party friends start touring Compton and New Orleans to huge crowds of non-white people.

Hell, those guys march in Washington, D.C. all the time. The city is more than 50% black. They didn't persuade many black people then...

Bob
04-10-2010, 07:08 PM
there's a tea party protest in boston on wednesday (sarah palin will be there, great). we have black people here, i'll check it out and see if many show up

DroppinScience
04-10-2010, 09:12 PM
there's a tea party protest in boston on wednesday (sarah palin will be there, great). we have black people here, i'll check it out and see if many show up

See if you can find any Asians too!

Documad
04-10-2010, 10:34 PM
Also, I find it highly suspect that a black man wrote: and senior citizens bopping to a hip-hop rapper.

Maybe the black guy wrote the first draft and then someone else edited it. The whole thing is curious. I don't usually pay attention to CNN --frankly I never cared for it but now they're just basically putting blogs and tweets and polls on the "news" instead of reporting. But how odd that they have this guy do this blog and then send notices to the looney right wing bloggers to try to publicize the blog. They've done some odd ball stuff lately, but they can't possibly think that they're going to move in on Fox's territory. :confused:

But back to the point. My city was recently the site of a sizeable rally for Palin and it supposedly turned out the tea partiers. This happened in an urban city where we have a sizeable minority population (and a black congressman). I scanned the footage of the event and I didn't see a black person anywhere. Frankly, I hardly saw any guys.

I don't doubt that there are black republicans. They have Michelle and Michael for instance. And that guy who ran against Obama for the Senate, right? But I'll need a lot more evidence to believe that this is a diverse national movement.

DroppinScience
04-10-2010, 11:43 PM
I don't doubt that there are black republicans. They have Michelle and Michael for instance. And that guy who ran against Obama for the Senate, right? But I'll need a lot more evidence to believe that this is a diverse national movement.

Don't forget J.C. Watts and P.K. Winsome (http://www.nofactzone.net/wp-content/images/pk.jpg)!

By Michelle and Michael you mean...? I'm assuming Michael is Michael Steele, but who is Michelle?

I agree with you that I'm also disappointed in the direction CNN is taking. Way too many Twitter updates and Facebook stuff. Do real reporting!

DroppinScience
04-11-2010, 04:01 AM
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/03/26/AR2010032603335.html?sid=ST2010032603551

First there was the KKK, then there was George Wallace, and now there is the Tea Party.

Bob
04-11-2010, 05:11 AM
i think comparing the tea party to the KKK might be a bit much

RobMoney$
04-11-2010, 10:59 AM
By Michelle and Michael you mean...? I'm assuming Michael is Michael Steele, but who is Michelle?

I'm assuming she was refering to Malkin.


I agree with you that I'm also disappointed in the direction CNN is taking. Way too many Twitter updates and Facebook stuff. Do real reporting!

I understand you may be disappointed that they seem to be moving away from bieng the liberal lapdogs that they once were. Hell, you can't blame them for wanting a piece of FOX's pie. I mean at the end of the day they are running a business and they are slaves to the almighty dollar.
Face it, liberalism is out. The Tea Party is the hot item right now and is becoming a force in American Politics, and everyone wants a piece.

Twitter and Facebook updates are just a sign of change in society. I like to recieve my news in more traditional fashion too, but you can't blame CNN for trying to remain current with how society recieves information.

DroppinScience
04-11-2010, 11:55 AM
I'm assuming she was refering to Malkin.

Michelle Malkin is an Asian (specifically Filipino), not black. I know it's tough to tell the difference.




I understand you may be disappointed that they seem to be moving away from bieng the liberal lapdogs that they once were. Hell, you can't blame them for wanting a piece of FOX's pie. I mean at the end of the day they are running a business and they are slaves to the almighty dollar.
Face it, liberalism is out. The Tea Party is the hot item right now and is becoming a force in American Politics, and everyone wants a piece.

Twitter and Facebook updates are just a sign of change in society. I like to recieve my news in more traditional fashion too, but you can't blame CNN for trying to remain current with how society recieves information.

CNN has never been a "liberal lapdog." Just like you pretend you don't watch FOX (but link to it), you pretend you watch CNN but haven't watched it.

In fact, the big problem with CNN is they are, in fact, spineless. FOX is known as the network for the right, MSNBC has now become the network for the left. CNN is actually afraid of taking any stances (and doing real reporting, it seems now).

They are actually over-reliant on Twitter and Facebook statuses that they almost don't do primary reporting now. I watched their coverage of the death of the Polish president on the plane crash yesterday. It's like they forgot how they did things before either of these existed. They pretty much just spent their time relaying that random people are grieving. Maybe they should have gone to Warsaw and got that from the people on the street themselves.

Documad
04-11-2010, 12:16 PM
Michelle Malkin is an Asian (specifically Filipino), not black. I know it's tough to tell the difference.

Rob was right. I meant Malkin. She was in my head because she was publicizing the blog that was the reason for this thread.

That was my fault. I was going to talk about minorities in general but then went and said "black." :o

So Rob gets points for reading my mind when I was wrong.

RobMoney$
04-11-2010, 12:24 PM
I thought she was black until Brett was kind enough to inform me of her specific racial makeup.
I had no idea.
Thanks Brett (y)



[/sarcasm]

Bob
04-14-2010, 08:33 PM
the rally was today but i forgot about it and overslept. oops.

it's alright i didn't really wanna be that close to sarah palin anyway